Legal studies and immigration: “It was a level playing field”
19 Nov 2026
A new book showcases the stories of legal scholars in German academia from migration backgrounds.
19 Nov 2026
A new book showcases the stories of legal scholars in German academia from migration backgrounds.
reads from the new book at Bucerius Law School | © Bucerius Law School
A new book edited by jurists Anatol Dutta from LMU Munich and Matteo Fornasier from Ruhr University Bochum presents the biographies of legal scholars in German academia.
A distinguished professor of Iranian origin experienced the law faculty as a closed circle when she began her studies in Vienna. Have you had similar feelings of alienation?
Anatol Dutta: No, I have never felt that my migration background was an issue. I began my studies here in Munich in 1997, and from the beginning I experienced the university and the law faculty as very open. My origins were not important; it was a level playing field. The State Examination, which is so crucial for a subsequent legal career, is graded anonymously, without regard to the candidate’s background. This gives everyone the same chance of success.
Together with Matteo Fornasier, you have compiled 35 biographies of law professors with migration backgrounds. How did you get the idea for this book?
There is a lot of talk about diversity today, including in legal studies. The term covers a wide range of different things, from gender equality to cultural background. It occurred to us that there are a large number of successful legal scholars with migration backgrounds, who rarely participate in these debates. We thought it would be interesting to explore to what extent their origins had shaped their careers, positively or negatively.
We also wanted to know to what extent their origins had influenced their choice of research topics. It is no coincidence, I think, that some of the contributors also practice comparative law and work on topics that go beyond German law.
Some of the accounts also emphasize that studying law in Germany opened up opportunities that would not have existed in their home country.Anatol Dutta, Chair of Private Law, Private International Law and Comparative Law at LMU Munich
What experiences do the legal scholars report in the book?
The spectrum is broad and covers a wide variety of origins, family histories, and career paths. There is the diplomat’s daughter from Iran who grew up in a sheltered environment in Vienna and attended a French school. Then there is the child of refugees from Lebanon, who grew up under very different conditions. Some were born in Germany, some came with their parents, and others arrived here to start an academic career. And some wonder whether they even qualify as having an immigrant biography – although they definitely do.
What unites these disparate biographies? Are there recurring patterns?
There are certain narratives that crop up again and again. One is the family and its importance as an anchor, and also as a hinge between societies. Some of the accounts also emphasize that studying law in Germany opened up opportunities that would not have existed in their home country.
Many of the biographies, however, reveal how fine the line often is between success and failure, how much can depend on serendipity.Anatol Dutta, Chair of Private Law, Private International Law and Comparative Law at LMU Munich
The book only contains success stories. Presumably there are also stories of failure?
Yes, absolutely. We did not intend the selection to be representative or to provide a solid empirical basis. Many of the biographies, however, reveal how fine the line often is between success and failure, how much can depend on serendipity. In the margins of the texts, as it were, we can thus glimpse the stories of those who did not manage to pursue an academic career.
I think most of the contributors view it as an enrichment, including for their research, not to be bound to just one society, one culture.Anatol Dutta, Chair of Private Law, Private International Law and Comparative Law at LMU Munich
© Tobias Targosz
The family as an anchor and a connection to the home country … living between two worlds can be an enrichment, but also a source of inner conflict.
This feeling of being between two worlds appears in many of the accounts. They describe what it is like to feel alien in both worlds, to not really be seen as belonging. Nevertheless, I think most of the contributors view it as an enrichment, including for their research, not to be bound to just one society, one culture.
How did you find the authors?
It required some detective work. Although Matteo Fornasier and I knew some of the authors personally, we had to search for other possible contributors. We went through the websites of German-speaking law faculties and trawled through forewords in dissertations, habilitation theses, and other publications. When we sent inquiries to our selection of around 50 scholars, almost all of them confirmed their migration background and the large majority agreed to participate. Many of them clearly saw the project as a welcome occasion for self-reflection. However, a small number did not want to speak publicly about their origins.
Interestingly, some of them write that once they entered university, many disadvantages, if they existed in the first place, basically disappeared, and their backgrounds became more of an asset, something positive.Anatol Dutta, Chair of Private Law, Private International Law and Comparative Law at LMU Munich
Law professors form a privileged caste, so to speak. You are successful in a field with great symbolic capital. Did the authors report encountering any structural difficulties or prejudices?
Interestingly, some of them write that once they entered university, many disadvantages, if they existed in the first place, basically disappeared, and their backgrounds became more of an asset, something positive. Likewise, the people who supported me in my academic career always saw my origins as something enriching, if it interested them at all.
But are there structural obstacles?
There is in fact a barrier against ‘late’ immigration in German legal studies: the State Examination. Without having passed this exam, it is difficult to gain a foothold in German universities. Consequently, in the doctoral and postdoctoral phases – during which many people come to German universities in other subjects – and afterwards as well, permanent moves to Germany are less common.
The accounts also show what this country has made possible for those telling their stories. They illustrate, therefore, how even a national subject like legal studies benefits from immigration.Anatol Dutta, Chair of Private Law, Private International Law and Comparative Law at LMU Munich
The book appears at a time of quite heated debates around migration. Is the volume, with its 35 success stories, also a kind of political statement?
No, we do not want to make a statement. We want the stories to stand for themselves, as they were recounted. But naturally the accounts also show how important immigration is for the country and what immigration can achieve. Taken together, they also show what this country has made possible for those telling their stories. They illustrate, therefore, how even a national subject like legal studies benefits from immigration.
Prof. Dr. Anatol Dutta is Chair of Private Law, Private International Law and Comparative Law at LMU Munich.
Anatol Dutta, Matteo Fornasier (eds.): Migrationsbiographien in der deutschen Rechtswissenschaft. Verlag Mohr Siebeck, Tübingen 2026; 711 pages, Euro 34; a digital version of the book is freely available at https://doi.org/10.1628/978-3-16-200860-2.